No announcement yet.

Which one would you pick & why?

  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Which one would you pick & why?

    If you were going to Magic Kingdom for the afternoon- and you wanted to do a sit- down Dinner. Which place would you pick? And why?

    I would like to see Everyone's choice and the reason why, because I am having a hard time deciding on which sit-down place in Magic Kingdom would be good.

    Thank you for Participating....
    Kate from PA

    1994 Dixie Landings, 1998 ASMu, 2000 ASMo, 2002 CT, 2003 Caribbean Beach, 2004 Outside WDW, 2005 Caribbean Beach, 2006 ASSp, 2007 Coronado Springs, 2008 BC, 2012 WL, 2013 POR, 2014 Caribbean Beach, 2015 BWI, 2015 PC, 2016 Disneyland, 2017 POFQ, 2018 BWI, 2018 ASMu with the Heidke Family! 2019 CS w/ Wanda Anderson.

  • #2
    I would pick The Plaza because I like the location on Main Street, the menu, and ice cream for dessert.


    • #3
      The Crystal Palace for donkey hugs with Eeyore!

      Enjoying some relaxation time on the Transatlantic cruise on the Disney Magic - I'm Cheryl and with my husband Mark, we love visiting Disney and exploring the world...


      • BriarRose4
        BriarRose4 commented
        Editing a comment
        Donkey hugs with Eeyore are the best!

    • #4
      Liberty Tree Tavern...I like Thanksgiving food any time of the year.
      That might sound boring, but I think the boring stuff is the stuff I remember the most.
      WDW Sept 1995 Contemporary - July 1997 & 1998 Polynesian - July 2000, 2003 & May 2019 Grand Floridian - Oct 2021 Beach Club - Sept 2022 AKL


      • #5
        I haven't had a sit-down dinner or meal in MK in many years. Probably Liberty Tree Tavern. I've only had lunch there and I remember if being good. Though, if it were me, and I was only there in the afternoon and evening, I'd just eat at Columbia Harbor House or Cosmic Rays to save time.


        • lovewdw2
          lovewdw2 commented
          Editing a comment
          Thank you but there will be a total of 5 of us...

      • #6
        Definitely Liberty Tree Tavern. The food is excellent and the Ooey Gooey Toffee Cake is to die for. It's not fancy, but I've never had a bad meal here and we visit every trip.


        • #7
          We tend not to eat sit down dinners at MK too often anymore but if I were to choose one restaurant then it would be Liberty Tree Tavern for their Thanksgiving meal!
          "If you can Dream it, you can do it. Always remember that this whole thing was started with a Dream and a Mouse." - Walt. E. Disney
          1975 Off-site, 1982 Poly, 1985 CR, 1987 Poly, 1988 Off-site, 1990 Off-site, 1992 - 2018 CBR, CR, POFQ, CS, ASM , POP, WL (CC & BL), YC, BW, BWV, OKW, GF, GFV, BCV, BLT, AKL, DL (GC)


          • #8
            For one reason or another, we don't do sit down at Magic Kingdom every trip. That said,, we will be eating at Liberty Tree Tavern in May because we haven't been here in a while and have always like the Thanksgiving dinner menu here.
            29 Trips to WDW
            2 Trips to DLR
            2 Disney Cruises (Wonder and Magic)
            1 Trip to Aulani/Hawaii


            • #9
              Liberty Tree Tavern ~food is delicious!
              "Laughter is timeless, imagination has no age, and dreams are forever." ~ Walt Disney

              Previous trips: June 1994 (offsite); July 1996 (offsite); May 2006 (offsite); May 2008 (offsite); May 2011 (offsite); June 2012 (POR); June 2014 (AKV - Kidani); June 2017 (POR); January 2018 (BC & YC); June 2019 (Pop Century)


              • #10
                I would have to go with the Plaza as the few times we've eaten there, it's been good.

                The last time we ate at Tony's, the food was on the table pretty much as soon as we ordered it so you could tell everything was made and just sitting there waiting. If I want "that kind" of food, I'll go to a buffet.

                As for the buffet - Crystal Palace - unless you get a first seating, lines for some reason always build up here. If you don't care if you see the characters, it's not a problem but it's the only buffet I've ever been at on Disney property with actual lines. The last time we were there, they had CM's from the kitchen out front handing out plates encouraging people to just go up to what they want to alleviate the lines. Some people didn't listen and then shot me dirty looks when I did just that.

                The one time we ate at LTT the food was okay but the service was sub par. We were given platters of food for two people, not 3, the frozen drink we ordered was messed up and the server still gave it to us saying up front "it's not right but you won't have to pay for this one." I don't think we should have gotten it in the first place, she should have said they weren't being offered that day. And that's not to mention after we did get the drink and the food, we didn't see the server again until I told Lenny and Abby to leave the table and then people rushed over wanting to help me, a single person sitting at a table full of dirty dishes - and it wasn't our server, it was other servers.

                My Previous Trips: All WDW - July 1980 off property - July 1981 FW - July 1983 FW - July 1985 FW - August 1987 FW - July 1988 Treehouse Villas - July 1990 Treehouse Villas - July 1997 FW - August 2006 AS Sports, 1st time with DH and DD - August 2008 AS Sports - August 2009 AS Sports - August 2010 AS Sports - July 2011 AS Sports - August 2013 AS Music - August 2014 AS Music - August 2015 AS Music - August 2016 AS Music - August 2018 AS Music - August 2021 AS Movies


                • #11
                  Kate, I am always hard pressed to choose between Liberty Tree Tavern and Crystal Palace. I think, if I were you, I would go for LTT for one reason, ooey gooey toffee cake! Plus, they just serve such lovely comfort food! Okay, that’s two reasons.

                  DLR off-site June 1979, WDW offsite March 1985, ASMovies June 2002, ASSports May 2006, ASMusic May/June 2007, ASSports May 2008, Pop Century May/June 2010, Coronado Springs October 2011, ASSports May/June 2012, Pop Century May/June 2013, ASMovies October 2013, DLR off-site June 2014, ASMusic May/June 2015, ASSports May/June 2016, ASMovies October 2016, Pop Century May/June 2017, MNSSHP October 2017, ASSports March 2018, Pop Century July 2019, AoA December 2020, ASMovies Sep 2021, Disneyland June 2022


                  • #12
                    Certainly LTT for me. Great comfort food and service.
                    Trips:95-2K,06&13-Italy, Switz, France, UK, Holland, Germany, Austria, Czech, Lich, Eire, Spain, Portugal, Moroc; 98-Nat.Parks(CA, AZ, UT & NV) 99-Vegas, 01-Austr, NZ&HA, 05-Memphis, 11-Austin:ACL& Orlando:Bay Hill;13-Paris & East France;15-Memphis;18-Vegas
                    WDW:02-WL, 03-CSR, 04-AKL, 05-BWI, 07-POR, BC, 08-CG Omni & CBR, 09-Poly, POR(Decade of Dreams), 10-POFQ, GF, 11-POFQ, 12-CSR,WL, 14-POR, 15-DCL Magic-West Caribbean, 16-B Resort, 17-USF:Royal Pacific/WDW Dolphin


                    • #13
                      I like Skipper Canteen. The atmosphere is very cool and relaxing. The menu is a bit different and very good. I have always had a good meal and good service.